🔗 Share this article

At an opulent speakeasy-style event at the Raffles hotel in central London this week, prominent figures from the remaining ranks of the Conservative party marked the Spectator’s annual political honors.

Given the publication's stance still just about backing the Tories, even as they confront severe challenges posed by Reform, it was unsurprising that much of the gossip during the upscale reception was about the security of the leader's position was at risk.

Leadership Tensions Emerge at Awards

One senior figure, who unsuccessfully ran, made pointed remarks from the stage targeting the obvious aspirations of a fellow frontbencher, Robert Jenrick – who is Badenoch’s biggest threat.

“Am I after her job? Will I make a move between her shoulder blades and steal the crown? Certainly not,” the veteran Tory cabinet minister told the laughing audience as he opened the evening's proceedings.

The runner-up from last year, and has been pitching alarmingly to the right to counter Reform's influence, did at least manage to chuckle. His own manoeuvres are far from discreet.

Deadline to Leadership Contest Starts

Earlier this year, a dissatisfied MP set up a countdown clock online showing remaining time before party regulations permit leadership bids. That clock reaches zero this weekend.

From then on, opponents within the party can formally request to trigger a contest. Revised guidelines established recently to increase the threshold, meaning 30% from parliamentary colleagues are now needed, previously just fifteen percent, creating a higher bar for potential challengers.

Potential Challengers and Backing

Is it feasible for opponents – primarily Jenrick – secure support from colleagues needed to initiate proceedings? Party sources reference previous nomination totals in the leadership contest: 28 in the first round. “That’s your starting point,” according to insiders.

There is no shortage of Conservative legislators ready to express their frustrations about Badenoch: her approach, her political judgment, her public appeal. However, generally, they are hesitant about committing yet another act a leadership overthrow so soon.

Breathing Space and Poll Anxieties

Several party members further think the leader's conference address during the fall gathering, announcing a policy to remove property tax on primary homes, has bought her temporary relief.

“Although dissatisfied with the current leadership we will act cautiously regarding a change. The public already think we engage in internal conflicts. We don’t need to give them further confirmation,” an anonymous legislator stated.

That is not to say planning has ceased. “The leader has until spring. The local elections could be disastrous for us. No one will desire to assume leadership preemptively and bear responsibility. But afterwards, we must find a leader who can take us in a new direction,” a frontbench source said.

Survey Figures and Voter Opinion

The polls already suggest the leader has gained minimal ground with the public in the past twelve months and that she has fallen in terms of her personal ratings. At -22 points, she is less popular than Jenrick (-16) and another colleague, per recent polling.

Data from YouGov also shows that Badenoch has convinced only 12% of Britons she is ready for higher office. However, the picture is better with party supporters, with 54% saying they approve of her performance as party leader, with fewer than a third saying she should not lead the party into the next general election.

Future Scenarios and Party Dynamics

Despite mixed feelings among base voters, there appears to be a consensus within parliamentary ranks that a change is inevitable to lead the party into the next election.

The key disagreement centers on timing to replace her in May to potentially halt Reform’s momentum – or leave it until closer to the general election if Reform falters, and voters could be more willing to listen to the Tories again.

Widely known that the challenger believes he is the right candidate. But his allies say he won't act immediately, and is among those who thinks they should wait until spring.

Alternative Candidates and Strategies

There is also a theory that a rescuer could emerge may end up being somebody less prominent figures (one junior minister Claire Coutinho gets mentioned) or among newer MPs without strong associations to previous governments.

Another former candidate, is also cited as a potentially unifying figure, remaining reserved. Supporters indicate he sees no better option but to carry on with Badenoch, as anybody taking over now would inherit an even more difficult situation.

Should a race begin, some would certainly urging Cleverly to stand, and he may be persuadable to give it another shot. A small group moderate legislators are already preparing opposition efforts to block the frontrunner leader in any eventual contest.

Conservative Shift and Political Calculations

A well-connected Tory warned how the “energy is all on the right” within and beyond the party, citing figures such as several prominent MPs. “It is a chance for James given his experience and membership connections, while others oppose Jenrick completely.”

“Many are considering potential agreements with the rival party eventually. Recent parliamentary divisions regarding social issues generated significant ‘we need to kick the people who voted for those out the party’ while Reform privately is ‘you’ve got some Lib Dems you’d have to get rid of’. That tips things the challenger slightly.”

However, another added: “Jenrick winning is not a foregone conclusion. We could have a strong competition between Jenrick and another – other prominent figures. The assumption that conservatives always wins the membership is not necessarily the case.”